Magic Spoon Quietly Drops Protein Pastries exclusively at Target

Written By Kaitlyn Kenna Smith

Magic Spoon just made a very quiet move — a new protein pastry SKU, available only at Target, not even listed on the Magic Spoon website yet.

No press blast. No influencer wave. Just… on shelf.

So let’s talk about what this actually is — and whether it deserves the “protein pastry” label.

What They Released - The Facts

  • Product: Magic Spoon Protein Pastries

  • Retail: Target exclusive (for now)

  • Flavors: Strawberry, S’mores, Cinnamon Brown Sugar

  • Category: Shelf-stable, toaster-style pastry with added protein

This clearly follows the 2025 protein pastry trend (Legendary, My Cookie Dealer): convenience, nostalgia flavors, and protein-forward marketing.

Now for the no-BS part.

Label Reality Check (Powerhouse Breakdown)

Based on the nutrition panel provided, here’s the honest framing:

The Positives

  • Higher protein than a traditional pastry

  • Lower sugar than standard Pop-Tarts

  • Convenient, grab-and-go

  • Flavor lineup makes sense for the category

For someone upgrading from ultra-processed breakfast pastries, this is objectively a step up.

The Tradeoffs - This Is Where Honesty Matters

This is not a “clean protein food,” and it’s not meant to be.

  • Protein-to-calorie ratio is okay, not elite (170 calories with 11g protein doesn’t hit that 10:1)

  • This is protein-enhanced food, not a protein source you’d build a day around

If you compare this to:

  • Whey + oats

  • Greek yogurt + fruit

  • Eggs + toast

…it loses on protein density and micro-nutrition, obviously. It could be a sweet tooth killer, but it better be DELICIOUS or I believe it’s not worth it.

Flavor Expectations - No Hype, Just Logic

Without ranking or over-selling:

  • Strawberry: Likely the safest, most forgiving flavor

  • Cinnamon Brown Sugar: Nostalgia-forward, usually the strongest in pastry formats

  • S’mores: Most polarizing — chocolate pastry flavors tend to expose formula weaknesses fastest

Translation: these flavors will live or die on texture, not macros.

Powerhouse Verdict

These pastries make sense for who they’re actually for:

✔ Busy mornings
✔ Travel days
✔ “I want something sweet but better than bullshit snacks” moments

They do not replace:

  • Protein shakes

  • Real meals

  • High-quality whole-food breakfasts

Magic Spoon isn’t trying to build athletes with this product — they’re owning the better-for-you convenience lane, and this fits that strategy perfectly.

Just don’t confuse better with optimal.

Kaitlyn Kenna Smith
Next

Dragon Pharma Releases New WheyPhorm Cappuccino Protein